Why Can Women Talk About Men Like This?

CChris Williamson
정신 건강결혼/가정생활

Transcript

00:00:00- Who was better in bed, Jennifer Aniston or Megan Fox?
00:00:04- Oh my God, it's making me uncomfortable.
00:00:06The trouble you get me in if I even attempt to answer that.
00:00:09- Sorry, I'm digging into your personal history.
00:00:11It's really awkward for you.
00:00:13- I'm flattered that you bring up my exes that way.
00:00:16But yeah, that kind of question,
00:00:19if a man is to give an answer,
00:00:21it kind of makes people uncomfortable, right?
00:00:23But there's been a recent incident
00:00:26where the kind of exact mirror incident has happened
00:00:29where a woman has been asked
00:00:31and it's total crickets in terms of controversy,
00:00:34except for my fire tweet.
00:00:36I come in to record an episode with you
00:00:39and then one hour after leaving,
00:00:41I write a tweet that becomes my most viral one of all time,
00:00:45except maybe Olly Moore's incident and classic.
00:00:47So it's got me back in here again
00:00:49before my flight back to Ireland.
00:00:51All right, let's see this clip.
00:00:53- Who was better in bed?
00:00:54That is really hard
00:00:59because Brad was like the sort of major chemistry,
00:01:04love of your life kind of like at the time, you know?
00:01:07And then Ben was like, technically excellent.
00:01:10(both laughing)
00:01:14- Holy fuck, I can't believe my daughter's listening to this.
00:01:18- Technically excellent, yeah.
00:01:20- So, I mean, I think she finessed the question pretty well.
00:01:26She handled it, that could have gone so much worse.
00:01:29But my tweet in response to this clip was,
00:01:32imagine Brad Pitt just jumping onto Modern Wisdom
00:01:35or jumping onto Joe Rogan or Andrew Huberman
00:01:38and discussing who was better in bed, Angelina or Jennifer.
00:01:42You know, it just would have a visceral reaction.
00:01:45The internet would explode and, you know,
00:01:48it's just a huge glaring double standard.
00:01:51And when I say that she finessed that pretty well,
00:01:55it could have been a lot worse.
00:01:56Like she could have, there could have been a clear winner.
00:01:59(both laughing)
00:02:00Like that would be really bad, you know?
00:02:04At face value, it's not too bad
00:02:05to have both guys described pretty well.
00:02:08But it was funny.
00:02:09A couple of guys in the responses to my post said,
00:02:13oh, imagine how embarrassing it would be
00:02:16to be Ben Affleck there,
00:02:18that you had to work to put in effort of technical skill,
00:02:22whereas Brad Pitt had the raw passion
00:02:24there without even having to try.
00:02:26It's like, come on,
00:02:27how much of a precious princess do you want to be?
00:02:30But ultimately the whole thing
00:02:31just brings in a huge double standard.
00:02:33- If you need to break down someone's sex skill
00:02:35like Bill Belichick, that's fine.
00:02:38But I think if you were to ask women
00:02:41how much they think that guys talk graphically about sex,
00:02:45they would be surprised at how much
00:02:47we never, ever, ever talk about sex.
00:02:49To every single woman in the world,
00:02:54your boyfriend and your guy friends
00:02:55do not talk about sex graphically with their friends at all.
00:02:58If you started talking about something
00:03:00that you got up to with a girl that wasn't funny,
00:03:02if it's a funny, weird story,
00:03:04you ended up shitting yourself when you were asleep
00:03:06after a one-night stand or you were about drunk over,
00:03:08whatever, whatever, okay, that's kind of newsworthy.
00:03:10But if you tell me in deep depth what you get up to,
00:03:15it sort of turns this ick switch inside of me
00:03:19that is really horrible.
00:03:20- Yeah, but that's the sex difference anyway,
00:03:24in terms of how much detail women share
00:03:26about all aspects of their social life.
00:03:29They go into a lot of detail,
00:03:30whereas men are more surface level.
00:03:32Like you'll come home from a evening out
00:03:34with your guy friends and your missus will ask you
00:03:38all of these questions about your friends.
00:03:40"How's the baby?"
00:03:41And it's like, "Baby, didn't even realize."
00:03:43You know, they go into so much more detail
00:03:45and that includes sexual exploits.
00:03:48So that is a surprising sex difference.
00:03:50And look, there is a sex difference
00:03:53in how harmful it might be.
00:03:55You won't hear me, a member of the bus lab,
00:03:58who, you know, researches sex differences
00:04:01and sexual conflict all the time.
00:04:04We know that it is much more harmful.
00:04:06Sexual violence and sexual harm towards women
00:04:09is more harmful towards women than it is to men.
00:04:11It's like, but it probably warrants a bit more discussion
00:04:15because I think the way the question was phrased
00:04:19is not something most men would enjoy.
00:04:21I don't think most men would enjoy that direct comparison.
00:04:24And also this type of comparison,
00:04:27a lot of people have said to me,
00:04:28"Oh, well Howard Stern has been doing that since the '90s."
00:04:31And I'm thinking Howard Stern is universally regarded
00:04:35as like gutter kind of locker room talk at best.
00:04:40"Call Her Daddy" is one of the most popular podcasts
00:04:43in the world and listened to by loads of women.
00:04:46And it kind of speaks to maybe this larger meta point
00:04:50of the, you know, so much is said
00:04:52about the negative influence of manosphere influencers
00:04:56or male podcasts, bros, like yourself even,
00:05:00your episode with Stephen Bartlett on "Diary of CEO,"
00:05:03you got in massive trouble over it.
00:05:06Whereas, you know, the "Call Her Daddy" podcast,
00:05:08I'm not a massive expert on it,
00:05:10but as far as I can tell, it does promote a lot of women
00:05:13to enjoy casual sex and be kind of engaged in that life
00:05:17and kind of trivialises it a little bit
00:05:19and makes it into kind of an entertainment
00:05:21and encourages women to almost make their life
00:05:24an entertaining story like that.
00:05:27And from a mating psychologist perspective,
00:05:31that is a hugely harmful message to young women.
00:05:34We know the data are very clear
00:05:36that it's vanishingly few women
00:05:38who benefit psychologically from casual sex.
00:05:41Most women have a terrible experience.
00:05:43In fact, one study found that the only predictor
00:05:47of a positive experience during casual sex
00:05:50in a large study was being male.
00:05:53So it's like, you know, Louise Perry always talks about,
00:05:57oh, this hookup culture benefits
00:05:59the unrestricted sociosexual people.
00:06:02And those are predominantly male, overwhelmingly male
00:06:05and vanishingly few women.
00:06:06So, you know, the larger kind of meta point
00:06:09is what is the influence of some of these female influencers?
00:06:13And in our previous episode,
00:06:15we talked about angry young women.
00:06:18I'm not saying that call her daddy or making women angry,
00:06:21but when I reposted the clip
00:06:25and made the comments that I did,
00:06:27there was this one comment from a female lawyer
00:06:29or law student that said,
00:06:31if Brad Pitt did do that,
00:06:33you'd have an army of young men laughing along with them
00:06:37and relishing it.
00:06:38And that kind of opinion can only take hold
00:06:43if you're extrapolating the behaviour
00:06:45of the edgiest edgelords on the internet
00:06:48and using that to think that's how men are like writ large.
00:06:52And it's just not the case.
00:06:53And it just kind of made me sad
00:06:55to think that she would come to that conclusion.
00:06:57And it's that type of thing
00:06:58that does make a generation of young women
00:07:01really angry at men or hate men,
00:07:03have really low opinion of them.
00:07:05- Why do you think it is that that sort of conversation,
00:07:09if you're talking quite openly about stuff that,
00:07:11I mean, it's, again, Gwyneth played it off pretty well,
00:07:14apart from the Bill Belichick bit.
00:07:16Is that not kind of like a cultural equivalent
00:07:23of sharing a nude?
00:07:24To talk about what happened intimately
00:07:27between you and somebody else,
00:07:28is that not kind of supposed to be done
00:07:30in a sort of confidence?
00:07:32- Yeah, absolutely.
00:07:33And there's no consent.
00:07:34We hear an awful lot about consent,
00:07:36but no one consented to that as far as I'm aware,
00:07:39unless Brad and Ben have privately given consent.
00:07:42And it can cause an awful lot of problems
00:07:45outside of just the obvious, the personal embarrassment.
00:07:47And you might think,
00:07:48oh, well, a lot of men would enjoy that.
00:07:50And it's kind of advertising their prowess to others.
00:07:54But it could cause a lot of conflict
00:07:55for their current or future relationships.
00:07:58So, you know.
00:07:59- Oh, tactically great, were you?
00:08:01Tactically great in bed?
00:08:02- Right.
00:08:03- Tactically great in bed with Gwyneth Paltrow, were you?
00:08:04- Exactly.
00:08:05What were you doing for her?
00:08:06You're not doing it for me?
00:08:07- Absolutely, could cause an awful lot of conflict there.
00:08:10But also there might be a lot of variability
00:08:13that yes, a lot of men might enjoy
00:08:15that being spoken about in these terms,
00:08:18but a lot of men don't.
00:08:20Like these are like on average group differences.
00:08:22And we have data that men, you know,
00:08:25don't perceive being sexually harassed
00:08:29in any way near as harmful as women perceive it.
00:08:32But there's a lot of variability.
00:08:33There are some men who really would hate that.
00:08:37- I did a poll one time on,
00:08:39have you heard of hot dudes reading?
00:08:42- Yes.
00:08:43- So this is, were you ever caught in the act?
00:08:45- No, I don't read publicly that much
00:08:47and I haven't caught enough.
00:08:48- Okay.
00:08:49Well, anyway, it's this kind of candid photo group
00:08:52of hot guys who are caught reading.
00:08:55And this is very sexually exciting to a lot of women.
00:08:58So there's a whole page for these guys.
00:09:01And I ran a poll to say, I think I saw somebody,
00:09:04maybe George Tinman commenting about how this is an invasion
00:09:08of their privacy.
00:09:08And I kind of thought that was a little bit of a reach.
00:09:11And I thought most men would absolutely love
00:09:13to be featured in such a--
00:09:15- Hot dudes reading?
00:09:15- Yeah, it's a great boost.
00:09:17But I did the poll and I think it was something like
00:09:2016% of men said they would hate it.
00:09:23And you know, there is a lot of variability
00:09:27in how men might perceive being spoken about.
00:09:29And again, the key thing is the comparison.
00:09:32Men don't typically like to be compared to.
00:09:34And maybe that's one of the reasons
00:09:35why they don't want to have these discussions all that much
00:09:39is because women compare prowess.
00:09:41- I think the main point to drive home
00:09:43is how little guys talk about this stuff with their bros.
00:09:46Around a dinner table,
00:09:47I've never had a conversation like that.
00:09:49I think guys might talk a little bit more about
00:09:53sex sort of on the front end.
00:09:55I hooked up last night.
00:09:56I slept with this bird last night.
00:09:58Oh, what happened after you went out, da, da, da, da, da.
00:10:00But way less on the back end
00:10:01of what were the sort of nitty gritty details?
00:10:04What happened graphically?
00:10:05What do you and your girlfriend get up to?
00:10:06What do you and your long-term partner get up to?
00:10:08Women, I think would be much more likely
00:10:10to hide what they do on the front end.
00:10:12If you have a one night stand,
00:10:13have to assume that there would be less likely
00:10:15to tell their friends than the guy would.
00:10:16But seem to be much more open
00:10:19about what they're getting up to on the back end.
00:10:21Maybe it's the, how would you say like,
00:10:25charitable interpretation is,
00:10:26well, if you're paying compliments
00:10:28to the guys that you've been sleeping with
00:10:30and you don't have a male brain,
00:10:32but you think you know what a male brain wants,
00:10:33you go, well, if I'm saying something good,
00:10:36that's just picking him up, right?
00:10:37He's hot dude's reading.
00:10:39This is the sex equivalent of hot dude's reading.
00:10:41Apart from the fact that it causes all sorts of problems
00:10:44if this gets back to somebody that they're now dating.
00:10:47And also, I don't know whether every guy does want
00:10:49their Bill Belichick gameplay analyzed.
00:10:52Yeah, and like I said,
00:10:54only for Gwyneth really finessed the question.
00:10:57It may not have gone that way.
00:10:58It may have been, oh yeah, Brad was great,
00:11:01but Ben did this horrific thing or whatever.
00:11:04It could have easily gone that direction.
00:11:05So the question was designed to cause friction and conflict.
00:11:10So it wasn't planned,
00:11:12that it would be so gracefully handled.
00:11:15But I do think you point out something interesting
00:11:17in the way that women exchange information like that
00:11:20and the reasons why they do.
00:11:22So in female friendships,
00:11:23it's very important for women to show vulnerability
00:11:26to each other so they're not seen as threatening.
00:11:28And being a bit overly promiscuous
00:11:31or having an embarrassing story or a sexual exploit
00:11:34is kind of seen as information that women share
00:11:37and expect similar information shared in return.
00:11:40So I was talking with my girlfriend about this
00:11:42and in female friendship groups,
00:11:44if one person shares a story like that,
00:11:47they're almost waiting immediately for the return story.
00:11:52Rally it back to me, give me an embarrassing story
00:11:54or a sexual story from your perspective.
00:11:56And if it doesn't- - Mutually assured
00:11:57destruction. - Yes, and if it doesn't come,
00:12:00then that person is seen as, oh, not a good ally,
00:12:03is not willing to play by the rules here.
00:12:07- Were there any other weird responses
00:12:09that you got to that or any other surprising responses?
00:12:11It really went fucking ballistic.
00:12:13It went absolutely interstellar.
00:12:14And I think we're gonna see more of this
00:12:16as Steve Stewart Williams' new book comes out,
00:12:20"Billion Years of Sex Differences,"
00:12:22as the talk about the differences between men and women
00:12:26becomes less taboo because kind of the more woke,
00:12:29super progressive overreach of 2020 has dropped away.
00:12:32These sorts of conversations and maybe some double standards
00:12:36are gonna get called out more and more,
00:12:37and that's gonna mean that people
00:12:39are gonna have to face this.
00:12:40But I don't know whether there was anything else
00:12:42that you thought was interesting that you came up against.
00:12:44- Yeah, I mean, the main sentiment
00:12:45was a lot of people saying, oh, well, it is different,
00:12:48and men and women are different,
00:12:49and just get with the program,
00:12:50which I thought was kind of ironic
00:12:51to be told that by the internet,
00:12:54given that our lab focuses so much on sex differences.
00:12:57So in my supervisor, David Buss, in his book,
00:13:00he either begins it or finishes it
00:13:03with a quote from intersectional feminist Kimberly Crenshaw,
00:13:08which I thought was a really clever move,
00:13:10but she's quoted as saying,
00:13:12"Treating different things the same
00:13:14"can generate as much inequality
00:13:16"as treating the same things different."
00:13:18I thought it was a really smart move.
00:13:20But it's exactly right.
00:13:21You know, it's not quite the same.
00:13:23Men and women aren't the same.
00:13:24They perceive sexual harassment
00:13:26and sexual harm very different.
00:13:28We have data on that.
00:13:30But like I said, that hides a lot of the variability.
00:13:33So, you know, yeah, you're right.
00:13:35It is, you know, it's interesting that people
00:13:39who ordinarily would rail against sex differences
00:13:42were so quick to invoke them when it suited.
00:13:44It's like, oh, you know,
00:13:46they'd usually rail against sex differences,
00:13:48and then suddenly it suits them to do so,
00:13:51and they're like, oh, no, it's not the same.
00:13:53So, yeah.
00:13:53What do you think would have happened
00:13:54if a guy had done that, but in reverse?
00:13:56- I think it would be a huge scandal.
00:13:58I really do think it would be like cancellation level stuff.
00:14:02And perhaps you might say rightly so.
00:14:04It's a bit ugly.
00:14:06I don't enjoy it when I see it too much.
00:14:07I can't think of any other example.
00:14:09Some people in the comments were saying
00:14:11that John Mayer had an example
00:14:12where he apparently said that Jessica Simpson,
00:14:15it was like a crack.
00:14:17He was addicted to it, couldn't stop.
00:14:19Again, complimentary, but perhaps is not perceived as such.
00:14:23But I can't recall a similar incident
00:14:25because I think we would all recognize it
00:14:27as really kind of ugly.
00:14:29- I'd feel lucky.
00:14:30I'd feel lucky if I saw that.
00:14:32It's, I don't know, man.
00:14:33This is, it's so funny to think about, you know, guys,
00:14:36the highly socio-sexual, lethario, misogyny,
00:14:40sort of red pill consuming, manosphere types.
00:14:42And then if you start to talk deeply
00:14:46about this sort of stuff,
00:14:47everyone gets a little bit sheepish and shy.
00:14:50- Yeah, we're not good on the details.
00:14:51We're like it either happened or it didn't.
00:14:54Don't go too deep, like you said.
00:14:56- Yeah, yeah, yeah.
00:14:58Before we continue,
00:14:58most people in their thirties are still training hard.
00:15:01Their protein is dialed in.
00:15:02They sleep better than they did in their twenties.
00:15:04Discipline is not the issue,
00:15:06but recovery feels somewhat different.
00:15:09Strength gains take a little longer.
00:15:11The margin for error starts to shrink.
00:15:13And that is why I'm such a huge fan of timeline.
00:15:16You see, mitochondria are the energy producers
00:15:19inside of your muscle cells.
00:15:20As they weaken with age,
00:15:21your ability to generate power and recover effectively
00:15:24changes even if your habits stay strong.
00:15:27Mitopure from timeline contains
00:15:29the only clinically validated form of erythilin A
00:15:32used in human trials.
00:15:33It promotes mitophagy, which is your body's natural process
00:15:36for clearing out damaged mitochondria
00:15:38and renewing healthy ones.
00:15:39In studies, this supported mitochondrial function
00:15:42and muscle strength in older adults.
00:15:44It's not about pushing harder.
00:15:45It's about actually supporting the cellular machinery
00:15:48underneath your training.
00:15:49If you care about staying strong
00:15:51into your thirties, forties and fifties and beyond,
00:15:53this is foundational.
00:15:55Best of all, there is a 30 day money back guarantee
00:15:57plus free shipping in the US and they ship internationally.
00:16:00And right now you can get up to 20% off
00:16:02by going to the link in the description below
00:16:04or heading to timeline.com/modernwisdom
00:16:06and using the code modernwisdom at checkout.
00:16:08That's timeline.com/modernwisdom
00:16:10and modernwisdom at checkout.
00:16:14Congratulations, you made it to the end of a clip
00:16:16and the full length episode is available right here.
00:16:19Go on.

Key Takeaway

Publicly comparing sexual partners reveals a clear societal double standard, as women's detailed disclosures of sexual history are often culturally tolerated while equivalent actions by men would likely cause a major, reputation-destroying scandal.

Highlights

  • A notable double standard exists where women comparing sexual partners in public media faces little controversy, while identical behavior by men would likely trigger a massive, career-damaging scandal.

  • Data indicates that the only consistent predictor of a positive experience during casual sex is being male.

  • Men and women show a measurable difference in communication styles: women typically exchange detailed information about sexual history to establish vulnerability and trust, while men prefer surface-level, goal-oriented discussions.

  • A poll revealed that approximately 16% of men find unsolicited sexual objectification or being featured on platforms like 'hot dudes reading' to be an invasion of privacy.

  • Research in mating psychology suggests that popular media content promoting casual sex as a trivial form of entertainment can have negative psychological outcomes for young women.

Timeline

The Sexual Comparison Double Standard

  • Publicly ranking sexual partners causes different levels of outrage depending on the gender of the person sharing.
  • A recent viral clip shows a woman comfortably comparing the sexual performance of two famous ex-partners with minimal public backlash.
  • Society lacks a consistent framework for how sexual history and partner comparisons are discussed across different media platforms.

Public discourse displays a glaring double standard regarding sexual partner comparisons. When a woman discusses the sexual merits of previous partners on a popular platform, the reaction is often measured or amused, whereas an equivalent action by a man would likely lead to immediate and widespread public condemnation. This disparity highlights how society processes information about sexual history and privacy differently based on the gender of the speaker.

Gender Differences in Sexual Communication

  • Men rarely engage in graphic or deep-dive discussions about sexual encounters with their friends.
  • Women use shared vulnerability regarding personal or sexual stories to build rapport and trust within their friendship groups.
  • Casual sex culture frequently benefits individuals with unrestricted sociosexual orientations, who are overwhelmingly male.

Communication patterns concerning sex differ sharply by gender. Women often exchange intimate or embarrassing sexual stories to show vulnerability and secure similar, reciprocal disclosures from friends. Conversely, men maintain a more surface-level approach, generally avoiding the granular, graphic details of sexual acts. Furthermore, research indicates that the psychological benefits of hookup culture are heavily skewed toward males, with very few women reporting positive experiences from such encounters.

Consent, Privacy, and Variable Perceptions

  • Discussing intimate sexual details without the partner's consent creates significant potential for personal and relational conflict.
  • Research shows that men and women perceive sexual harassment and unsolicited attention with different levels of intensity.
  • Approximately 16% of men express discomfort when being sexually objectified or featured in candid public content.

The public analysis of sexual performance without partner consent raises issues of privacy and potential harm to future relationships. While some assume men would universally welcome sexual attention or validation of their 'prowess,' data indicates significant variability; many men feel uncomfortable with such comparisons. Publicly analyzing a partner's sexual behavior is viewed as an infringement on privacy, yet current social norms treat this behavior inconsistently depending on who performs it.

Community Posts

View all posts