Transcript

00:00:00are you familiar with nietzsche's idea of resenting man the slave and master morality
00:00:04no tell me so nietzsche basically believed and i agree with him that
00:00:11like we'll apply to modern day context poor and middle class people not all of them but some of
00:00:16them they seem to be obsessed with the concept of morality and virtue and it's not that morality or
00:00:23virtue are bad but they weren't able to get external success they weren't able to get money
00:00:28they weren't able to get the good wife whatever the nice house so they don't really have the life
00:00:35that they want and so what they do is they move the goalposts from external success to internal virtue
00:00:41which they conveniently get to define so now i don't have to win in life instead what i can do
00:00:46is i can just say oh but i'm a good person who defines what a good person is you because it's
00:00:52subjective to you so it's almost like a free cop-out now i'm not saying by any means that you shouldn't
00:00:57want to be a good person or that virtue and character aren't i feel like my dad's gonna listen to this
00:01:02and he's gonna be like oh my gosh yeah what are you saying like shout out shout out jet's dad yeah
00:01:06shout out shout out my dad but you have to understand that like people are constantly coping it's
00:01:13subconscious it's they're not even aware of it and then i for me i just can't stand these people
00:01:18because they're so obsessed with morality and virtue and they're like oh i hate all these people
00:01:22when it's like i don't think you're aware that what you're doing is just code because you couldn't
00:01:26get the external success i'm not saying external success is everything in life right there's nuance
00:01:31to this of course but nietzsche recognized this he realized that it's like hey these people they're
00:01:36kind of just making up some bullshit to make themselves feel better and that's what happens
00:01:42and i mean i'm a christian myself but a lot of christians do this where they're like oh you know
00:01:47people online say that jesus is the personification of slave morality you know the person they have
00:01:52resentment built up against the people that are successful then they switch they they get to
00:01:57choose what's actually right but the thing is is that jesus is not slave morality at all because
00:02:02slave morality comes from a place of resentment and jesus didn't have resentment so i really hate that
00:02:07narrative online but it's like you'll you i will admit that you see this a lot in christian
00:02:13communities or whatever where they're kind of be like ah like you know it's it's harder for surely
00:02:19i tell you that it's harder to get in the kingdom of heaven than for a camel to walk through a needle
00:02:23whatever that bible verse is and they're like you shouldn't get money like that's anti-christian
00:02:28and it's like well you could do amazing things with money you can help people with money it's
00:02:32it's not inherently oh yeah it's cope it's cope it's so hope so the problem is you go online you
00:02:37say that you are it's funny because i i've posted a few videos on this over the over my time on social
00:02:43media and every time i get stitched a hundred times everyone's like you know this guy jet of touch
00:02:50yeah and it's funny because they'll be like you know you'll get a comment he actually thought we
00:02:53were going to agree with him no i i didn't think you were going to agree with me i was just willing
00:02:56to say what needed to be said but these people are it's just everywhere you go you see cope cope cope
00:03:01i used to be that guy that's how i know right and i'm not saying everyone does this i'm not saying
00:03:05everyone that is concerned about being a good person is doing it out of resentment for people
00:03:11that have external success not saying that at all but a very large percentage of them surely are it's
00:03:16such a cheap shot as well like it's so predictable before you look at the comment section you can
00:03:21already see like this is out of touch he doesn't understand he thinks that the only thing that matters
00:03:26is materialism and yeah there's this idea idea from isaiah berlin called the inner citadel familiar
00:03:32with that very similar to what you're talking about so he says um when the path to human fulfillment is
00:03:37blocked we retreat into ourselves into a kind of inner citadel where we're walled off against all
00:03:42of the fearful ills of the world and we make our own laws so an example of this would be um your leg
00:03:48gets injured in a battle and you have the choice to either try and rehabilitate the leg but if you
00:03:54can't rehabilitate the leg then you cut your leg off and announce that the desire for legs is
00:03:58misguided and must be subdued yeah yeah like this we see it everywhere people that say weight has no
00:04:06bearing on health because they've struggled to lose weight people who say that jobs are for suckers
00:04:10because they've struggled to hold one down and they turn to a life of crime people who have been uh
00:04:15cheated on and found it difficult to get a relationship to work so they turn to polyamory
00:04:20or they become incels like at each of these different i guess it would be vol cells uh at each of these
00:04:29different junctures what somebody is doing is saying the world's denied me that which i want
00:04:34i'm going to rewrite the rules retreat into myself so that i no longer need to face the reality that i
00:04:39could get it if i did something different and again like this is there's two very very unpopular
00:04:45things to talk about online there's many but like two that are kind of reliable philosophically one of
00:04:49them is that and the other is the arrival fallacy if you say the view from the top of the mountain
00:04:54that you're climbing up is not going to be as satisfying as you think it is you sound like a fat
00:04:59guy at a buffet telling someone who's starving that food doesn't taste that good yeah like you suck the
00:05:04engine out of them and the oxygen gets pulled out of the room it's seen as uh like bourgeois it's seen
00:05:13as judgmental as opulent and rightly so you a person who has the thing that i want are telling me a
00:05:20person who doesn't have that thing and wants it that the thing i want won't satisfy me but how many people
00:05:28that have got a problem with their self-worth or a scarcity mindset reach some level of success or fame
00:05:38or monetary notoriety and then go oh man all my inner problems were solved it was so great like so
00:05:46one of two things is happening with that which is the first one it is true that when you achieve
00:05:52something that you try to fill an internal void with an external success it's not going to reliably work
00:05:57yeah the other one is that everybody that reaches a level of success is part of some weird cult cabal
00:06:05that's all cartelling to convince other people to like pull the ladder up after them
00:06:09so that they it's like no one else can win exactly exactly it's like oh it's not that good i'm
00:06:14fucking idiots yeah like no that's obviously not the case it's obviously the case that people can't
00:06:19fill internal voids with external accolades yeah most people don't realize how much being dehydrated
00:06:24impacts their performance which is why for the last five years i've started pretty much every morning
00:06:29with element element is a tasty electrolyte drink mix with everything that you need and nothing that
00:06:34you don't this orange salt in a cold glass of water is like a sweet salty orangey nectar and i really
00:06:42tell the difference when i take it versus when i don't it plays a critical role in reducing muscle
00:06:46cramps and fatigue helps to optimize brain health and regulate your appetite while also curbing cravings
00:06:52best of all there are no questions asked refund policy with an unlimited duration so you can buy it
00:06:56and try it for as long as you want and if you don't like it for any reason i'll just give you your money
00:07:00back plus they offer free shipping in the us right now you can get a free sample pack of elements most
00:07:05popular flavors with your first purchase by going to the link in the description below or heading to
00:07:09drink l m n t dot com slash modern wisdom that's drink l m n t dot com slash modern wisdom congratulations
00:07:17you made it to the end of a clip and the full-length episode is available right here go on

Key Takeaway

When external success or fulfillment is blocked, individuals retreat into an internal citadel to redefine morality out of resentment rather than addressing internal self-worth.

Highlights

  • Resentment causes individuals to move goalposts from external success to subjective internal virtue.

  • Isaiah Berlin's Inner Citadel theory illustrates how people rewrite rules and retreat inward when human fulfillment is blocked.

  • Physical injury, career failures, and relationship struggles often trigger individuals to claim that their original desires were misguided.

  • Achieving external success, fame, or monetary notoriety fails to solve underlying internal self-worth issues or fill internal voids.

Timeline

Nietzsche's Resentment and the Shift to Internal Virtue

  • Inability to achieve external success prompts people to shift focus toward subjective internal virtue.
  • Redefining morality creates a self-serving mechanism to avoid external competition.
  • True Christian theology contrasts with slave morality because genuine virtue lacks underlying resentment.

When individuals fail to secure money, personal relationships, or material wealth, a coping mechanism occurs where external success is devalued. Morality becomes a subjective tool that the individual defines to maintain self-esteem without achieving external goals. Online discussions often misinterpret religious figures like Jesus as representations of slave morality, ignoring that slave morality strictly stems from resentment. Money itself is not inherently anti-Christian, as financial resources enable positive real-world actions.

Isaiah Berlin's Inner Citadel and Defense Mechanisms

  • Isaiah Berlin's Inner Citadel concept explains how individuals retreat inward when path fulfillment fails.
  • People declare original desires misguided after failing to achieve specific goals.
  • Subconscious psychological shifts appear across health, career, and relationship domains.

Blocked paths to human fulfillment drive individuals into an internal citadel where they create personal laws to protect against harsh reality. A soldier unable to rehabilitate an injured leg might sever it and declare the desire for legs misguided. Similar dynamics appear when individuals assert weight has no impact on health after struggling with weight loss, or claim jobs are unnecessary after failing to maintain employment. Rewriting rules shields individuals from confronting actions required for genuine success.

The Arrival Fallacy and External Void Misconceptions

  • Warning others about the limitations of success often triggers severe public backlash.
  • External accomplishments cannot resolve internal self-worth issues or scarcity mindsets.
  • Successful individuals do not withhold achievement to protect personal advantages.

Informing individuals that reaching top-tier goals will not satisfy them creates immediate hostility, making the speaker appear dismissive or opulent. People struggling with self-worth assume external accolades will repair internal issues, but monetary notoriety and fame consistently fail to fill internal voids. The belief that successful people discourage others merely to pull up the ladder ignores the reality that external praise cannot fix internal psychological deficits.

Community Posts

View all posts