“Men are punished for a patriarchy they can’t remember”

CChris Williamson
Mental HealthJob SearchCollege EducationParentingWeight Loss/Nutrition

Transcript

00:00:00I think, again, it's really strange
00:00:03for me to be thinking about,
00:00:05sort of talking about this from the outside,
00:00:07given that so much of my content crosses over.
00:00:10But I think that much of the hunger
00:00:15for what I'm talking about and these guys too,
00:00:20is a sort of reaction to a felt lack of sympathy
00:00:24and sort of denial of male pain.
00:00:26And I think if there were,
00:00:27if there was more of an acceptance of
00:00:30guys are having a tough time of it at the moment,
00:00:33through pretty much any objective metric,
00:00:35I don't think that any group
00:00:37has fallen further faster than men.
00:00:38That's Richard Reeves line
00:00:40from the American Institute of Boys and Men.
00:00:42If it wasn't for the fact that there were no places to go,
00:00:48I think fewer guys would go to the internet.
00:00:50And that creates both kind of the cause,
00:00:56it creates an opening in the market.
00:00:59What's that line about?
00:01:00If there are no role models, if you can't propose any,
00:01:04and I think that this is a really great question.
00:01:07In fact, for you, who do you think are some good examples
00:01:10of sort of genuine positive role models
00:01:13that you would say to your boys,
00:01:15you should, this would be the sort of man
00:01:18that you should emulate?
00:01:20- Well, I mean, the answer that gets bandied around a lot
00:01:24over here in the UK is Gareth Southgate,
00:01:27like the former England manager.
00:01:29I think he embodies a certain sort of dignity
00:01:35and sense of fair play, and obviously in a pursuit
00:01:40that many boys aspire to excel in, many girls too.
00:01:43I mean, how long, should I come up with a couple more?
00:01:49Like, there's clearly in the pantheon of program makers,
00:01:53in my field, David Attenborough, an adventurer,
00:01:57a world-bestriding colossus of naturalism,
00:01:59a sensitive human being.
00:02:01I mean, I think it is worth saying in that scenario
00:02:05that you've depicted of kind of male failure, if you like,
00:02:09like men despairing, that thing of deaths of despair,
00:02:14like suicides and drug overdoses.
00:02:18We should also, as a father of boys,
00:02:21I often remind myself that the two things that matter most
00:02:24to my kids at various times have been football,
00:02:28English football, obviously, Premier League football,
00:02:30and rap, grime and drill, and those are both worlds
00:02:33in which most of the preeminent, world-famous,
00:02:37highest-paid, highest-achieving exponents are men,
00:02:41and worlds in which, in fact, homosexuality is considered
00:02:45still rather questionable and taboo,
00:02:47like not many openly gay footballers,
00:02:50not that many openly gay rap artists.
00:02:53So there are, I guess I'm pushing back ever so slightly
00:02:57in the sense that there are still realms in which,
00:03:00you know, most of the most successful comedians
00:03:02are probably still men.
00:03:04Like, there are still realms in which not just men,
00:03:08but a kind of traditionally masculine-presenting man
00:03:11is still ascendant.
00:03:13- No, I would agree.
00:03:14I think the difference is between where do the guys
00:03:17who raise to the top and where does the mean,
00:03:21the average man, end up sitting?
00:03:23Because the average man is not gonna become
00:03:24a Premier League footballer or Ricky Gervais.
00:03:27The average man is increasingly slipping away
00:03:29from going to university, increasingly slipping away
00:03:32from getting a high-paying job,
00:03:33increasingly more likely to be addicted to drugs
00:03:35or video games or porn or weed or whatever.
00:03:37And you're right, you're right to say that men dominate
00:03:42the extremes, but they dominate the extremes at both ends.
00:03:47And it's a denial of the slipping back.
00:03:50I think that this is my read that if it wasn't for the case,
00:03:55that I am struggling as a man.
00:03:58Well, look at your privilege.
00:03:59Look at all of these CEOs.
00:04:01Look at all of the football players.
00:04:02Look at how well, and it goes, yeah, but I'm struggling
00:04:06and maybe many of my friends are too.
00:04:09And there doesn't seem to be a sympathetic place
00:04:11to land for that.
00:04:12- Yeah, I totally agree.
00:04:13And I think I'm not a fan of the casual disparagement of men.
00:04:18And I think very occasionally, maybe more than occasionally,
00:04:21that happens, like typical man or step back as a man,
00:04:26check your privilege, especially as a father to boys.
00:04:32Like boys, I never wanna be in a world in which boys
00:04:36have kind of inherited an original sin
00:04:38by dint of being boys.
00:04:39You know, it's like, oh, well, you have to,
00:04:43as a boy, you've somehow, your bequest is the fact
00:04:46that men have tended to run society for hundreds of years.
00:04:50Like, no, he's like five years old, like seven years old.
00:04:53Like don't put that on him, do you know what I mean?
00:04:56I know, I was joking the other day.
00:04:58Like I remember growing up and they were like,
00:04:59you remember that nursery rhyme,
00:05:01what are little girls made of?
00:05:03And it's all like sugar and spice and all things nice.
00:05:05And what little boys made of like pigs and puppy dogs tails.
00:05:09I'm like, remember when it was like seven years old,
00:05:11why am I made of puppy dogs tails?
00:05:13You know what I mean?
00:05:14And then that's kind of trivial,
00:05:15but I don't like that sort of like frivolous denigrating
00:05:20of maleness and maybe I'm being over sensitive,
00:05:25but I think it kind of, it's a little unfair.
00:05:29So maybe I'm agreeing with that.
00:05:31But I think the other thing I'd say is,
00:05:33if I want to sound really apocalyptic,
00:05:37we are all both men and women now inhabiting a world
00:05:42in which technology is upended so much
00:05:45and promises to upend even more.
00:05:47Because God knows when, you know, in a world where,
00:05:49I know a lot of it's traced back
00:05:50to the decline of traditional manufacturing,
00:05:52also birth control, women entering the workplace,
00:05:56globalization of the economy, you know,
00:05:59and the fact that a lot of like, you know,
00:06:02manufacturing jobs moving to places like China
00:06:05and then actually most of the jobs
00:06:07like now can be done equally well or better by women.
00:06:12But in a world where AI is going to eliminate
00:06:15most of the jobs that involve sitting in front of a screen,
00:06:18as is sometimes promised,
00:06:19there's going to be this whole other rucktion.
00:06:21Like it's going to play out really interestingly, I think,
00:06:26to say the least, in terms of how men and women interrelate,
00:06:30like whether, you know, how sustainable,
00:06:32I don't know, I know I'm taking this a bit off tangent,
00:06:35but I sometimes think like that, you know,
00:06:40male mental health versus, you know,
00:06:42and how it figures in wider society will be subsumed
00:06:46by some vastly bigger social crisis.
00:06:49- Wow, yeah, do you know what it is?
00:06:51I hadn't drawn that part of the path
00:06:56down the circles of hell, but you're probably right.
00:06:59That it's all well and good talking about the issues
00:07:02that both men and boys and women and girls are facing.
00:07:06But when 50% of the workforce is displaced by AI,
00:07:10I don't know whether that's going to happen,
00:07:12when some percentage of the workforce is displaced by AI
00:07:14and people don't have meaning and certain jobs have jobs
00:07:17and other people don't feel like they've got a path forward.
00:07:19But it does loop back to what I said before,
00:07:22which is that if anything, if it requires anything,
00:07:26it requires sympathy.
00:07:28Like you need to be sympathetic.
00:07:30Wow, the world changed really fucking far,
00:07:34really fucking fast.
00:07:36That's hard to navigate.
00:07:39That's hard to navigate.
00:07:40But because at least at this iteration of it,
00:07:44the men were part of a previously beneficial group.
00:07:49They were part of one that seemed to be afforded privileges
00:07:52in certain domains, not the privileges to go to war
00:07:54and die and et cetera.
00:07:55But opportunities that weren't afforded to the women,
00:08:00it felt, and I think it feels to a lot of young men now,
00:08:05like they are being made to pay for the sins
00:08:09of the advantages that their fathers and grandfathers had.
00:08:11Like they're accused of being part of a patriarchy
00:08:14that they no longer feel a member of,
00:08:16when they're looking around and saying,
00:08:18"Well, where is my privilege?"
00:08:20And I think that it ties in with you talk to these two guys
00:08:25and there's a line that they say in life as a man,
00:08:28"You're born without value."
00:08:30And I think what they mean with that is it feels to me
00:08:34like there is a kind of love and belonging
00:08:39and acceptance and pedestalization
00:08:42that's given to women and girls
00:08:46that I haven't felt has been afforded to me.
00:08:48I haven't felt as special.
00:08:50I haven't felt as cared for unless I do something,
00:08:53unless I make myself big and impressive.
00:08:55And again, with that sympathy to go,
00:08:59"Fuck yeah, you know, previously it probably,
00:09:01there would have been a pretty linear progression
00:09:04for you to have found a place in society
00:09:06and done these things and cost of living
00:09:08and uncertain turbulent times
00:09:11and all of these different stimulus
00:09:13that can cause you to be addicted."
00:09:15And if you believe in life as a man,
00:09:18you're born without value,
00:09:19that probably requires some sympathy too.
00:09:22A quick aside, if you've noticed your energy
00:09:24isn't quite what it used to be,
00:09:25even though you eat well and stay active,
00:09:27there might be a reason for that.
00:09:28As we age, our mitochondria,
00:09:30which is the parts of our cells that produce energy,
00:09:32become weaker and make less energy,
00:09:34which is why I'm such a huge fan of timeline.
00:09:37They developed this pill right here
00:09:40that helps clear out damaged mitochondria
00:09:42so your cells can actually renew themselves.
00:09:44And this isn't just theory.
00:09:46In clinical trials, people saw mitochondrial renewal increase
00:09:49by more than 40% in just 16 weeks,
00:09:52along with improvements in their overall energy.
00:09:54Timeline is backed by over a decade of research,
00:09:56has more than 50 patents,
00:09:58and is the number one doctor-recommended
00:10:00mitochondrial supplement on the planet.
00:10:03I started taking it nearly two years ago
00:10:04because it was recommended to me by my doctor,
00:10:06and that is why I've used it for so long,
00:10:09since way before I knew who made the product,
00:10:11and that is why I partnered with them.
00:10:13Best of all, there's a 30-day money-back guarantee,
00:10:15plus free shipping in the US, and they ship internationally.
00:10:18So right now, you can get up to 20% off
00:10:21and that 30-day money-back guarantee
00:10:23by going to the link in the description below
00:10:25or heading to timeline.com/modernwisdom.
00:10:28That's timeline.com/modernwisdom.
00:10:31Congratulations for making it to the end of a clip.
00:10:33Your brain has not been fried by TikTok.
00:10:36Watch the full episode here.

Key Takeaway

The discussion explores the modern crisis of male identity, arguing that young men are being unfairly penalized for historical structures while simultaneously facing a lack of societal empathy and a precarious economic future.

Highlights

The growing "hunger" for certain online content is a reaction to a perceived lack of sympathy and the denial of male pain in modern society.

While men still dominate the highest levels of success in fields like sports and entertainment, the "average man" is statistically falling behind in education and employment.

Modern boys are often treated as if they have inherited an "original sin" or collective guilt for a historical patriarchy they were not part of.

The decline of traditional manufacturing and the rise of AI pose significant threats to male identity and future job security.

The concept that men are "born without value" suggests they must achieve greatness or provide utility to be afforded love and belonging.

There is a critical need for societal sympathy toward the rapid pace of change that has left many young men feeling displaced and without a clear path.

Timeline

The Lack of Sympathy for Male Pain

The speaker opens by identifying a significant void in the cultural conversation regarding the struggles of men. He suggests that the popularity of certain online figures stems from a widespread feeling that male pain is currently being denied or met with a lack of sympathy. Referencing Richard Reeves, the speaker notes that no group has fallen further or faster than men when looking at objective metrics. This section highlights how the absence of physical spaces for men to discuss these issues drives them toward internet subcultures for validation. It concludes by posing the vital question of who remains as a genuine positive role model for young boys today.

Role Models and the Extremes of Male Success

The speakers discuss potential role models like Gareth Southgate and David Attenborough, who embody dignity and sensitivity in their respective fields. However, they acknowledge a paradox where traditional masculinity remains ascendant in high-stakes environments like the Premier League and the rap music industry. The conversation notes that while these fields are dominated by men, they often remain conservative or taboo regarding topics like homosexuality. The speaker uses these examples to push back against the idea of total male failure by showing where men still excel. This section sets the stage for the distinction between the elites of society and the common experience of the average man.

The Disappearing Average Man and the Privilege Myth

The dialogue shifts to the "mean" or average man, who is increasingly slipping away from higher education and high-paying careers. While critics often point to male CEOs or athletes as evidence of "male privilege," the speakers argue this ignores the reality of those at the bottom who are struggling with addiction to drugs, video games, or pornography. Men dominate the extremes of society at both the top and the bottom, but the middle ground is eroding rapidly. There is a sense of frustration that individual male suffering is dismissed because of the success of a tiny percentage of the male population. This section emphasizes that there is currently no sympathetic place for the struggling average man to land.

The Burden of Original Sin and Technological Upheaval

The speakers express concern over the "casual disparagement" of men and the idea that young boys have inherited a form of "original sin" based on historical patriarchy. One speaker recounts the nursery rhyme "pigs and puppy dogs' tails" as an early example of the frivolous denigration of maleness that persists today. They argue it is unfair to burden a young child with the guilt of how society was run hundreds of years ago. The conversation then takes an "apocalyptic" turn, discussing how technology and birth control have upended traditional social structures. This section highlights how the decline of manufacturing and the looming threat of AI-driven job displacement will further complicate the relationship between the sexes.

Inherited Sins and the Search for Meaning

The final segment focuses on the psychological toll of being accused of belonging to a patriarchy that young men no longer feel a part of. The speaker notes that while grandfathers may have had certain advantages, modern young men feel they are being made to pay for those "sins" without receiving any of the benefits. They discuss the quote "as a man, you're born without value," implying that men are only cared for if they achieve something "big and impressive." The speakers conclude that the world has changed too fast for many to navigate, leading to a sense of displacement and a desperate need for social sympathy. This section ties the economic struggles of the cost-of-living crisis to the broader emotional neglect of the male experience.

Sponsorship and Closing Remarks

The video concludes with a sponsored segment for Timeline, a mitochondrial supplement aimed at improving energy levels as people age. The speaker details the science behind the product, mentioning its 50 patents and clinical trials showing a 40% increase in mitochondrial renewal. He shares his personal experience using the supplement for two years after a recommendation from his doctor. This portion serves as a commercial break and includes a call to action for viewers to check the link in the description for a discount. Finally, the host congratulates the audience for finishing the clip, jokingly noting their attention spans have survived the "TikTok fry," and invites them to watch the full episode.

Community Posts

View all posts