00:00:00I think, again, it's really strange
00:00:03for me to be thinking about,
00:00:05sort of talking about this from the outside,
00:00:07given that so much of my content crosses over.
00:00:10But I think that much of the hunger
00:00:15for what I'm talking about and these guys too,
00:00:20is a sort of reaction to a felt lack of sympathy
00:00:24and sort of denial of male pain.
00:00:26And I think if there were,
00:00:27if there was more of an acceptance of
00:00:30guys are having a tough time of it at the moment,
00:00:33through pretty much any objective metric,
00:00:35I don't think that any group
00:00:37has fallen further faster than men.
00:00:38That's Richard Reeves line
00:00:40from the American Institute of Boys and Men.
00:00:42If it wasn't for the fact that there were no places to go,
00:00:48I think fewer guys would go to the internet.
00:00:50And that creates both kind of the cause,
00:00:56it creates an opening in the market.
00:00:59What's that line about?
00:01:00If there are no role models, if you can't propose any,
00:01:04and I think that this is a really great question.
00:01:07In fact, for you, who do you think are some good examples
00:01:10of sort of genuine positive role models
00:01:13that you would say to your boys,
00:01:15you should, this would be the sort of man
00:01:18that you should emulate?
00:01:20- Well, I mean, the answer that gets bandied around a lot
00:01:24over here in the UK is Gareth Southgate,
00:01:27like the former England manager.
00:01:29I think he embodies a certain sort of dignity
00:01:35and sense of fair play, and obviously in a pursuit
00:01:40that many boys aspire to excel in, many girls too.
00:01:43I mean, how long, should I come up with a couple more?
00:01:49Like, there's clearly in the pantheon of program makers,
00:01:53in my field, David Attenborough, an adventurer,
00:01:57a world-bestriding colossus of naturalism,
00:01:59a sensitive human being.
00:02:01I mean, I think it is worth saying in that scenario
00:02:05that you've depicted of kind of male failure, if you like,
00:02:09like men despairing, that thing of deaths of despair,
00:02:14like suicides and drug overdoses.
00:02:18We should also, as a father of boys,
00:02:21I often remind myself that the two things that matter most
00:02:24to my kids at various times have been football,
00:02:28English football, obviously, Premier League football,
00:02:30and rap, grime and drill, and those are both worlds
00:02:33in which most of the preeminent, world-famous,
00:02:37highest-paid, highest-achieving exponents are men,
00:02:41and worlds in which, in fact, homosexuality is considered
00:02:45still rather questionable and taboo,
00:02:47like not many openly gay footballers,
00:02:50not that many openly gay rap artists.
00:02:53So there are, I guess I'm pushing back ever so slightly
00:02:57in the sense that there are still realms in which,
00:03:00you know, most of the most successful comedians
00:03:02are probably still men.
00:03:04Like, there are still realms in which not just men,
00:03:08but a kind of traditionally masculine-presenting man
00:03:11is still ascendant.
00:03:13- No, I would agree.
00:03:14I think the difference is between where do the guys
00:03:17who raise to the top and where does the mean,
00:03:21the average man, end up sitting?
00:03:23Because the average man is not gonna become
00:03:24a Premier League footballer or Ricky Gervais.
00:03:27The average man is increasingly slipping away
00:03:29from going to university, increasingly slipping away
00:03:32from getting a high-paying job,
00:03:33increasingly more likely to be addicted to drugs
00:03:35or video games or porn or weed or whatever.
00:03:37And you're right, you're right to say that men dominate
00:03:42the extremes, but they dominate the extremes at both ends.
00:03:47And it's a denial of the slipping back.
00:03:50I think that this is my read that if it wasn't for the case,
00:03:55that I am struggling as a man.
00:03:58Well, look at your privilege.
00:03:59Look at all of these CEOs.
00:04:01Look at all of the football players.
00:04:02Look at how well, and it goes, yeah, but I'm struggling
00:04:06and maybe many of my friends are too.
00:04:09And there doesn't seem to be a sympathetic place
00:04:11to land for that.
00:04:12- Yeah, I totally agree.
00:04:13And I think I'm not a fan of the casual disparagement of men.
00:04:18And I think very occasionally, maybe more than occasionally,
00:04:21that happens, like typical man or step back as a man,
00:04:26check your privilege, especially as a father to boys.
00:04:32Like boys, I never wanna be in a world in which boys
00:04:36have kind of inherited an original sin
00:04:38by dint of being boys.
00:04:39You know, it's like, oh, well, you have to,
00:04:43as a boy, you've somehow, your bequest is the fact
00:04:46that men have tended to run society for hundreds of years.
00:04:50Like, no, he's like five years old, like seven years old.
00:04:53Like don't put that on him, do you know what I mean?
00:04:56I know, I was joking the other day.
00:04:58Like I remember growing up and they were like,
00:04:59you remember that nursery rhyme,
00:05:01what are little girls made of?
00:05:03And it's all like sugar and spice and all things nice.
00:05:05And what little boys made of like pigs and puppy dogs tails.
00:05:09I'm like, remember when it was like seven years old,
00:05:11why am I made of puppy dogs tails?
00:05:13You know what I mean?
00:05:14And then that's kind of trivial,
00:05:15but I don't like that sort of like frivolous denigrating
00:05:20of maleness and maybe I'm being over sensitive,
00:05:25but I think it kind of, it's a little unfair.
00:05:29So maybe I'm agreeing with that.
00:05:31But I think the other thing I'd say is,
00:05:33if I want to sound really apocalyptic,
00:05:37we are all both men and women now inhabiting a world
00:05:42in which technology is upended so much
00:05:45and promises to upend even more.
00:05:47Because God knows when, you know, in a world where,
00:05:49I know a lot of it's traced back
00:05:50to the decline of traditional manufacturing,
00:05:52also birth control, women entering the workplace,
00:05:56globalization of the economy, you know,
00:05:59and the fact that a lot of like, you know,
00:06:02manufacturing jobs moving to places like China
00:06:05and then actually most of the jobs
00:06:07like now can be done equally well or better by women.
00:06:12But in a world where AI is going to eliminate
00:06:15most of the jobs that involve sitting in front of a screen,
00:06:18as is sometimes promised,
00:06:19there's going to be this whole other rucktion.
00:06:21Like it's going to play out really interestingly, I think,
00:06:26to say the least, in terms of how men and women interrelate,
00:06:30like whether, you know, how sustainable,
00:06:32I don't know, I know I'm taking this a bit off tangent,
00:06:35but I sometimes think like that, you know,
00:06:40male mental health versus, you know,
00:06:42and how it figures in wider society will be subsumed
00:06:46by some vastly bigger social crisis.
00:06:49- Wow, yeah, do you know what it is?
00:06:51I hadn't drawn that part of the path
00:06:56down the circles of hell, but you're probably right.
00:06:59That it's all well and good talking about the issues
00:07:02that both men and boys and women and girls are facing.
00:07:06But when 50% of the workforce is displaced by AI,
00:07:10I don't know whether that's going to happen,
00:07:12when some percentage of the workforce is displaced by AI
00:07:14and people don't have meaning and certain jobs have jobs
00:07:17and other people don't feel like they've got a path forward.
00:07:19But it does loop back to what I said before,
00:07:22which is that if anything, if it requires anything,
00:07:26it requires sympathy.
00:07:28Like you need to be sympathetic.
00:07:30Wow, the world changed really fucking far,
00:07:34really fucking fast.
00:07:36That's hard to navigate.
00:07:39That's hard to navigate.
00:07:40But because at least at this iteration of it,
00:07:44the men were part of a previously beneficial group.
00:07:49They were part of one that seemed to be afforded privileges
00:07:52in certain domains, not the privileges to go to war
00:07:54and die and et cetera.
00:07:55But opportunities that weren't afforded to the women,
00:08:00it felt, and I think it feels to a lot of young men now,
00:08:05like they are being made to pay for the sins
00:08:09of the advantages that their fathers and grandfathers had.
00:08:11Like they're accused of being part of a patriarchy
00:08:14that they no longer feel a member of,
00:08:16when they're looking around and saying,
00:08:18"Well, where is my privilege?"
00:08:20And I think that it ties in with you talk to these two guys
00:08:25and there's a line that they say in life as a man,
00:08:28"You're born without value."
00:08:30And I think what they mean with that is it feels to me
00:08:34like there is a kind of love and belonging
00:08:39and acceptance and pedestalization
00:08:42that's given to women and girls
00:08:46that I haven't felt has been afforded to me.
00:08:48I haven't felt as special.
00:08:50I haven't felt as cared for unless I do something,
00:08:53unless I make myself big and impressive.
00:08:55And again, with that sympathy to go,
00:08:59"Fuck yeah, you know, previously it probably,
00:09:01there would have been a pretty linear progression
00:09:04for you to have found a place in society
00:09:06and done these things and cost of living
00:09:08and uncertain turbulent times
00:09:11and all of these different stimulus
00:09:13that can cause you to be addicted."
00:09:15And if you believe in life as a man,
00:09:18you're born without value,
00:09:19that probably requires some sympathy too.
00:09:22A quick aside, if you've noticed your energy
00:09:24isn't quite what it used to be,
00:09:25even though you eat well and stay active,
00:09:27there might be a reason for that.
00:09:28As we age, our mitochondria,
00:09:30which is the parts of our cells that produce energy,
00:09:32become weaker and make less energy,
00:09:34which is why I'm such a huge fan of timeline.
00:09:37They developed this pill right here
00:09:40that helps clear out damaged mitochondria
00:09:42so your cells can actually renew themselves.
00:09:44And this isn't just theory.
00:09:46In clinical trials, people saw mitochondrial renewal increase
00:09:49by more than 40% in just 16 weeks,
00:09:52along with improvements in their overall energy.
00:09:54Timeline is backed by over a decade of research,
00:09:56has more than 50 patents,
00:09:58and is the number one doctor-recommended
00:10:00mitochondrial supplement on the planet.
00:10:03I started taking it nearly two years ago
00:10:04because it was recommended to me by my doctor,
00:10:06and that is why I've used it for so long,
00:10:09since way before I knew who made the product,
00:10:11and that is why I partnered with them.
00:10:13Best of all, there's a 30-day money-back guarantee,
00:10:15plus free shipping in the US, and they ship internationally.
00:10:18So right now, you can get up to 20% off
00:10:21and that 30-day money-back guarantee
00:10:23by going to the link in the description below
00:10:25or heading to timeline.com/modernwisdom.
00:10:28That's timeline.com/modernwisdom.
00:10:31Congratulations for making it to the end of a clip.
00:10:33Your brain has not been fried by TikTok.
00:10:36Watch the full episode here.