What Telling Men To “Man Up” Does To Them

English
CChris Williamson
Mental HealthParenting

Transcript

00:00:00people of the uk and ireland if you are coming to see me on tour i want to hear from you i want to
00:00:04know what problems you're dealing with your worst first date and any questions that you've got for
00:00:08me and i will be bringing some of you up on stage to talk about it so if you're coming to see me on
00:00:13tour this october go to chriswilliamson.live stories submit them and i might see you with
00:00:19a mic in front of your face very soon chriswilliamson.live stories does rsd look different
00:00:24in men um you want a weird answer for that sure okay i this is my soapbox for this i think that
00:00:36looking at just you know being a psychiatrist and seeing mental health just in general and seeing
00:00:41the progression of mental health especially as we've talked about it a little bit more you start
00:00:45to notice patterns and as you look at male mental health i think that we have done a huge disservice
00:00:52to men in terms of we don't educate men and help cultivate with men a lot of information about
00:01:00emotional sensitivity and as a result for a lot of men they know how to target a couple emotions
00:01:06and one of them being anger so i think for a lot of men you see men that have you know they've been
00:01:13told you know just man up this is not that big of a deal don't cry about it don't like they have
00:01:20been forced to suppress emotions but the only socially acceptable emotion they're allowed to express is
00:01:25anger i would say that some of that is probably misdirected or confusing signals of maybe emotional
00:01:30sensitivity what happens when emotionally sensitive bodies are told to man up i mean that you get really
00:01:37angry dudes and i mean it's just such a like i think as a parent who um has a son um it's weird because
00:01:48and maybe it's this is like the mom son thing that i'm so protective over him um but you know you see
00:01:56in other settings and you you start to really zoom in and you look at how other people are are
00:02:02bringing up their their six-year-olds their six-year-old boys and even from a young age in
00:02:08the kindergarten class you know the way that the girls are treated in the class versus the boys are
00:02:13treated in the class and not by the teacher right like the parents you look at it in birthday parties
00:02:17you know a girl will fall down they're scooped up they're they're coddled they're told you know
00:02:22everything is okay a boy will fall down and it's like oh that's not that big of a deal you know let's
00:02:26let's move on from this and it's it just it doesn't seem like it's like from genesis there's not like a
00:02:33huge spot where they can start to explore and really navigate emotional sensitivity well yeah i think
00:02:42emotionally sensitive women seem to have a bit more latitude and forgiveness to explore that kind of
00:02:49sensitivity than men do especially as they get into adulthood like i you know i think you're right that
00:02:55it's weird anger is such an anti-social emotion yeah right it's dangerous it can be destructive it's
00:03:01often not wanted by the people that are experiencing it and they don't want the impact of it to happen
00:03:05but anger is for many men more socially acceptable than sadness and when you think about how anti-social
00:03:13anger is as an emotion it really goes to show sort of how unaccepted sadness can be but yeah you know
00:03:20we talk a lot online about the importance of getting men to open up i had a conversation two
00:03:25conversations this week talking about male suicide and in both of them there is this i just wish that
00:03:31this guy had reached out i wish that he talked but in over 90 of cases where a man takes his own life
00:03:37in the uk he's already gone to some form of mental health counseling so it's not just the talking about
00:03:44it thing it's actually allowing like giving room for men to be able to feel their feelings and i think
00:03:49that to be honest like a lot of the blame a lot of the work not blame a lot of the work here can be
00:03:56laid at other men's feet because everyone says they want their friend to open up if you're having a bad
00:04:02time that i really need you to to talk to me and this is all easy to say after the fact especially
00:04:07if something really dangerous or devastating has happened but how many guys are supportive of
00:04:13another man on the internet that's opening up about how much he's struggling like not not to the
00:04:18overton emotional overton window of acceptability which is you know things are hard but i'm getting
00:04:23back in the gym and i'm gonna put some muscle on or whatever like really broken down and i don't know
00:04:28what to do i'm alone i'm broken i'm i'm lost i'm devastated uh a guy that's crying is aversive
00:04:36to a lot of men yeah and women too but like you don't get to say male suicide's a big problem we
00:04:42need to do more of more for this society needs to care more and then take the piss out of a guy who
00:04:48is opening up about his emotions online yeah i had this idea of man points which is guys need to
00:04:55accumulate sufficient kind of surplus masculinity in areas like muscularity or strength or success
00:05:02or money or notoriety or women or whatever and if they've got this bank account reserve of masculinity
00:05:09they can kind of withdraw from that and then talk about emotions it's like this special video game
00:05:14unlock that only happens once you've reached a particular level of being a man
00:05:19basically people have a big ick most of society has a big ick with men talking about deep emotions
00:05:25especially difficult emotions but they have far fewer if it comes from a place of prestige than one
00:05:31of poverty uh a guy who's already down on his luck and might not have much going for him talking about
00:05:37how much things are hurting doesn't get the same kind of sympathy that chris bumstead six time olympia
00:05:45world champion one of the most muscular guys on the planet that he gets he can cry and talk about how
00:05:49he broke down in his girlfriend's arms six weeks before he's about to win the world championship
00:05:53because he's got all of these trappings and trimmings of masculinity that make it seem like it's
00:05:58not coming from a place of weakness it's coming from a place of strength but again chris doesn't need
00:06:05the same kind of support because he's already got a community around him of a supportive wife and all of
00:06:11these successes that are continuing to move him down the track the people that really need it the guys
00:06:16that kind of don't have anything going for them and they're presumably going to be the biggest risk as
00:06:19well yeah but yeah that's my that's my soapbox as well to just i really wish that there was more
00:06:25latitude like speaking as a guy that feels feelings i just i did a a full week retreat working exclusively
00:06:30on emotions 12 hours a day for seven days in northern california last year two weeks ago i just did a
00:06:36jhana meditation retreat which is exclusively working on conductivity of emotions a silent meditation
00:06:42retreat for seven days like sitting on the cushion for i know six or eight hours a day so that was
00:06:48like both of those things for me i mean trying to get below the neck me trying to move away from a lot of
00:06:55the judge not even judgment like uh felt scrutiny yeah and um existing patterns of how is this going to
00:07:07show up in the world can i operate this way inside of my business is this something that i can do that's
00:07:11publicly acceptable it's like it doesn't you can go and work on this thing in isolation and then come
00:07:15back but yeah i i i know what it's like to be a really sensitive kid growing up that didn't have anywhere to
00:07:23put it because you're in a working class blue collar environment or the people around you
00:07:29don't notice or don't have the tools to be able to help and it can drive you to do really amazing things
00:07:36but it also creates a bunch of coping mechanisms that mean huh i had this weird gift like i had this
00:07:42depth of connection that i could have had with the world and i contorted it alchemized it you could
00:07:48say because it went from something that was a challenge to something that you've turned into something
00:07:51good yeah but it is kind of a denial of a bit of yourself as well at the same time so that's been
00:07:56this has been a it's one of the reasons i was excited to speak to you because it's a very personal
00:08:01like super interesting topic i think it's fascinating what a lot of emotionally sensitive people also
00:08:06they go through life and they hide that part of them because there's so much internalized shame about
00:08:11like you're not supposed to be sensitive you're supposed to be strong you're supposed to be able to
00:08:15handle stuff you're i mean male and females like i mean this is something that as a human condition
00:08:22people are are celebrated for like you were able to get on the other side of that adversity like you
00:08:26did so well you didn't complain you didn't do and so like you from a young age you just kind of learn
00:08:33to shut down that part of yourself or become really embarrassed i remember being like a kid and you
00:08:38know my mom something would happen and it would like hit my ear the wrong way and i i would think
00:08:45that oh my god like i'm so embarrassed or something and i would like go and hide i would like hide under
00:08:50a table or hide in a closet or because i was just like embarrassed and sad and everything happening
00:08:57all at once and eventually i was like this is young like eight i was like this is not conducive for me
00:09:05moving forward not functioning well yeah this is i can't do that when i'm grown up and so then you just
00:09:12start hiding it so if you're emotional or if you're having a hard day you lie about it you're like i'm
00:09:18fine i'm fine i'm fine it's not a big deal i don't want to talk about it or and sometimes i would
00:09:23be like i don't want to talk about it with other people because i'll cry and that'll prove that i'm
00:09:28emotionally sensitive and so i i hear that story a lot as well the insight that suppression isn't the
00:09:33same thing as strength yeah is i don't know kind of kind of world-changing that what you're doing if
00:09:40you're an emotionally sensitive person that's swallowing them down is you're performing the
00:09:46role of somebody who's got composure yeah but that's not the same as having composure that's
00:09:51not the same you're performing the role of somebody that hasn't felt the thing that's not the same as
00:09:55no not feeling the thing no and you've got this line the real challenge lies in not feeling deeply
00:10:00but in living in a world that doesn't always know how to support that sensitivity
00:10:06that's a good quote it's a great it's it's a great line it really is the real challenge lies
00:10:11not in feeling deeply but in living in a world that doesn't always know how to support that sensitivity
00:10:17yeah yeah the world feels very spiky every time i come back from retreat i always feel like
00:10:21everything is so tender i know and then what you get to see is how operating in a world that's
00:10:31incredibly intense very chaotic fast moving you have to create these strange patterns and coping
00:10:38mechanisms and wall yourself off and guard yourself just so that you can move through the day and that's
00:10:42fine right you don't want to be a whimpering blob on the floor you don't want to be a puddle i don't
00:10:47want to be a puddle of emotions i want to be able to show up but then also there are bits of your
00:10:50experience that you're denying yourself yeah and there are strengths that you can have that come along for
00:10:55this that's a question what are the strengths of highly sensitive people what are the strengths of people
00:10:59with rejection sensitive dysphoria yeah i think being able again i think that there is a direct pipeline
00:11:07between being highly emotionally sensitive and being highly emotionally intelligent and i think that's
00:11:11just how you deal with that sensitivity and so some of the strengths that can come with that emotional
00:11:18sensitivity are number one you have a deep deep deep understanding of other people's emotional
00:11:24insides and i think that's part of you know what led me into psychiatry in the first place that's part of
00:11:30why i've continued to enjoy it as much as i have because i think that you can intimately understand
00:11:37when people are talking about their experience or like you can even understand you know sometimes
00:11:42i'll have a patient come into my office and you start asking them questions and you know their answer is
00:11:48like i don't know like okay so can you tell me anything in the past two months that has really
00:11:55made you upset i don't know like and so then it's for a lot of people that's like a stone wall you don't
00:12:01really know where to go from there but for some people who are highly emotionally sensitive you're
00:12:05picking up like okay i'm picking up from like previous body cues that they were giving me when they were
00:12:10talking about their family or when they were answering in certain ways you're just like okay well there's some
00:12:15tension there and so you start asking about other questions so you're picking up stuff that you might
00:12:19not even have clocked as it was happening at the time but you've amalgamated and you know exactly
00:12:24what direction to go i think that's an incredibly um wonderful thing to have um and i think that yeah
00:12:32that outside of just psychiatry i think that does make you a good friend it makes you a good partner
00:12:36it makes you a good parent i think it's so helpful with parenting um so i think i think it's just that
00:12:44huge scope of understanding that emotional condition does emotional sensitivity have an impact on
00:12:50people's self-esteem um yes but sometimes it can be negative you know if you're highly emotionally
00:12:59sensitive i think and you're used to reading emotional data negatively sometimes that can
00:13:06start to impact your self-esteem and you're you're walking into a room and you know self-worth and
00:13:10self-confidence are different but you walk into a room and you start to feel like okay maybe i'm not
00:13:15wanted here and things like that and and you're reading emotional information and and possibly attaching a
00:13:22narrative on there that doesn't actually exist that can impact your self-esteem for sure um but there
00:13:28are other times like for example in the work that i do as a psychiatrist because of that emotional
00:13:34sensitivity i'm celebrated for that and i think it's a really unique field to be in as an emotionally
00:13:38sensitive person because that's one of the areas where i get the most validation because people feel
00:13:45like they have been understood for the first time a quick aside you've probably heard me talk about
00:13:49element before and that's because i've started every single morning the same way for the last
00:13:52five years now which is a cold glass of water with elements in it element is an electrolyte drink
00:13:57mix with everything that you need and nothing that you don't it's a science-backed electrolyte
00:14:00ratio of sodium potassium and magnesium no sugar no coloring no artificial ingredients it reduces
00:14:06muscle cramps and fatigue supports brain function and helps to regulate your appetite throughout the
00:14:10day i genuinely notice the difference when i take it versus when i don't which is why i don't shut up
00:14:15about it and also why it's used by everyone from dr andrew huberman to olympic athletes and fbi sniper
00:14:21teams the good sniper teams not the bad ones also there are no questions ask refund policy so if you
00:14:27don't like it for any reason they'll just give you your money back plus they offer free shipping in
00:14:31the us right now you can get a free sample pack of elements most popular flavors with your first
00:14:35purchase by going to the link in the description below heading to drinklmnt.com slash modern wisdom
00:14:41thank you very much for tuning in if you enjoyed that clip you will love the full-length episode in all of
00:14:50its glory right here come on press it

Key Takeaway

Suppressive social norms force men to channel deep emotional sensitivity into anger and isolate those lacking prestige when they seek support.

Highlights

  • Over 90 percent of men who take their own lives in the UK have already sought some form of mental health counseling prior to their death.

  • Suppression of emotion in men frequently results in anger, which remains one of the few socially acceptable emotional expressions allowed for males.

  • Childhood conditioning creates an environment where boys are told to move on quickly from physical or emotional pain while girls receive coddling.

  • Emotional sensitivity without accumulated social prestige or masculinity reserves often leaves struggling men vulnerable to societal dismissal and mockery.

  • Deep emotional processing requires moving away from social scrutiny through intensive isolation retreats like silent meditation or emotional workshops.

Timeline

Social conditioning of male emotional suppression

  • Society fails to educate men on emotional sensitivity, leaving anger as the primary permissible emotional outlet.
  • Childhood gender differences in responses to minor injuries reinforce emotional avoidance in young boys.
  • Over 90 percent of men taking their lives in the UK have previously attended mental health counseling.
  • Society penalizes vulnerable men who express deep emotional pain while rewarding those with high social prestige.

Men experience systemic discouragement from exploring emotional sensitivity from an early age, starting with kindergarten interactions where boys are told to move past injuries while girls receive comforting. This suppression restricts emotional vocabulary to anger, a dangerous and destructive emotion that remains socially acceptable compared to sadness. Despite widespread calls for men to open up, over 90 percent of male suicide cases in the UK involve individuals who already engaged with counseling. Online communities often mock men who express deep despair unless those men possess high status or masculinity reserves.

The concept of accumulated masculinity and social stigma

  • Men require a reserve of masculine prestige to safely discuss difficult emotions without facing social backlash.
  • High-status individuals receive immense sympathy for emotional vulnerability while ordinary men face isolation.
  • Intensive isolation retreats help individuals bypass social scrutiny and reconnect with buried emotional depth.
  • Childhood embarrassment drives sensitive children to hide their emotions and adopt coping mechanisms.

Men accumulate surplus masculinity through strength, success, notoriety, or wealth to build a bank account reserve that permits emotional expression. High-profile figures like world champions can break down publicly and receive support because their prestige protects them from appearing weak. Conversely, ordinary men lacking these advantages receive little sympathy when expressing distress. To overcome this conditioning, individuals often turn to intensive week-long emotional or silent meditation retreats to bypass public scrutiny and heal childhood coping mechanisms.

Strengths and challenges of high emotional sensitivity

  • Emotional suppression mimics composure but differs fundamentally from true emotional regulation.
  • High emotional sensitivity correlates directly with deep emotional intelligence and empathy.
  • Sensitive individuals possess a profound understanding of other people's internal emotional states.
  • Negative interpretation of emotional data can harm self-esteem despite providing professional advantages.

Swallowing down emotions constitutes a performance of composure rather than genuine emotional health. The real challenge involves navigating a chaotic world that fails to support high sensitivity. Despite the difficulties, emotional sensitivity provides a direct pipeline to high emotional intelligence, enabling exceptional intuition in professional settings like psychiatry, as well as strengthening interpersonal bonds in friendships and parenting. While misreading emotional cues can negatively impact self-esteem, embracing sensitivity ultimately allows for deeper human connection.

Community Posts

No posts yet. Be the first to write about this video!

Write about this video